Can soy actually protect against breast cancer?

A new study shows a surprising link between soy and a reduced risk of breast cancer

Can soy actually protect against breast cancer?

Source: Best Health Magazine, October 2012

Soy has long been a concern for women who have breast-cancer risk factors or have had the disease. The concern was due to a natural compound found in soybeans called soy isoflavones, which have a weak estrogen-like effect, says Dr. Xiao-Ou Shu, a professor and cancer epidemiologist at Vanderbilt-Ingram Cancer Center in Nashville, Tenn. Estrogen has been thought to promote the growth of breast-cancer cells. While it is true that soy isoflavones do have ‘some estrogen-like effect,’ says Shu, ‘it is much weaker than the actual hormone in the body.’

That’s a good thing, but what’s really exciting is that the latest and largest study to date in this area has actually linked eating soy to a reduced risk of breast-cancer recurrence. The study, published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, followed nearly 10,000 breast-cancer survivors from the U.S. and China for almost eight years. After monitoring the diets of these women, the researchers found that those who consumed at least 10 mg of soy isoflavones a day had a 25 percent lower risk of breast-cancer recurrence than those who ate less than four mg per day.

Experts have also previously worried that eating soy foods might interfere with the effectiveness of tamoxifen, a drug used to reduce the recurrence of breast cancer in women. The results of this study, however, showed that tamoxifen users who regularly consumed higher amounts of soy isoflavones had a lower risk of recurrence than women who did not take the drug and consumed the lowest amount of soy isoflavones.

‘What needs to be made clear is that this study was done based on dietary soy,’ says Shu. ‘There have been no studies done on whether the effect is the same from soy isoflavone supplements.’

This article was originally titled "Soy may protect against breast cancer" in the October 2012 issue of Best Health. Subscribe today to get the full Best Health experience’and never miss an issue!

Related content:

Secrets to Staying Healthy & Happy


Milking the issue

Just a little over a year ago, Facebook shut down profile accounts with photos of women nursing their kids. There’s now a revolt within the social network with more than 500 groups on breastfeeding, including the “Hey, Facebook, breastfeeding is not obscene!” group with more than 180,000 members, and “Breastfeeding in Canada, a call to […]


66 days to change: What we can learn from Canadian athletes

Canadian women have rocked these Sochi Olympics ‘ from yesterday’s astounding gold-winning performances by the women’s hockey and curling teams, to the Dufour-Lapointe sisters dominating moguls, to Kaillie Humphries and Heather Moyse making history as two-time bobsleigh gold medal winners. And, just this morning, Marielle Thompson and Kelsey Serwa won gold and silver in women’s […]

Women lose more muscle

If the promise of a lean, strong physique isn’t enough incentive to get you to pick up some weights as part of your workout, a scary study reported in the Globe and Mail might be enough to do the trick.It’s no secret that we lose muscle mass as we age – it’s part of the […]